Skip to main content
Home of the BBC on the Internet
News
Sport
Weather
World Service
Languages
WATCH/LISTEN TO BBC NEWS
Election 2005
Sport
Weather
On This Day
LANGUAGES
Chinese
Vietnamese
Indonesian
Burmese
Thai
Last Updated: Thursday, 28 April, 2005, 12:15 GMT 13:15 UK
Japan's rail training questioned
As wreckage was cleared away the front car became visible

The Japanese government has called on rail companies to review their training procedures in the light of Monday's devastating train crash.

One option being considered is a state supervised test for all train drivers.

The call came as emergency workers ended the rescue operation, after the death toll rose to 106. One of the dead was confirmed as the train's driver.

Rail union leaders said the crash may have been caused by the driver's fear of being reprimanded for running late.

"I wonder if we should be leaving driver qualification to train operators," Transport Minister Kazuo Kitagawa told reporters.

"Perhaps the government needs to be more actively involved in driver qualification and training," he said.

Doubts over driver

Accident investigators said the JR West train's 23-year-old driver, Ryujiro Takami, may have been trying to make up time.

Because of a mistake he had made at a previous station, Takami's train was running 90 seconds late - potentially disruptive on Japan's meticulously scheduled rail network.


A data recorder recovered at the crash site showed that the train was travelling 100km/h (62mph) at the time of the accident - well above the 70km/h limit for that section of track.

Stones on the rails have also been suggested as another possible factor in the crash.

The BBC's correspondent in Tokyo, Jonathan Head, says questions are being raised about the obsession with punctuality in Japan.

According to railway employees, they can be subject to severe punishment if their trains run late.

"The accident is a result of JR West's... high-pressure management, which uses terror to force its employees to follow orders," Osamu Yomono, vice-president of the Japan Confederation of Railway Workers' Unions, told reporters.

He said punishment included ordering errant workers to repeatedly write "meaningless" reports or undertake humiliating tasks.

JAPAN'S RAIL SAFETY RECORD
1963: Freight train crashes into derailed Tokyo commuter train, 161 killed
April 1991 - 42 killed when two trains collide near Shigaraki
March 2000 - Tokyo underground train crashes into derailed train, killing five
April 2005 - Crash near Osaka kills at least 89
Mr Yomono pointed out that the dead driver had been put through "re-education" before, and may have been trying to avoid another session.

He had only been in the job for 11 months, but is reported to have been reprimanded twice in his previous job as a conductor, and once last year as a driver for a platform overrun.

Rescuers found Takami's body on Thursday. Shortly after that, the mangled remains of the first carriage were finally dragged out from under the apartment block in the western city of Amagasaki that it struck on Monday.

Rescue workers have been using high-tech sensor equipment to listen for heartbeats or breathing, but no-one has been found alive in the wreckage since early on Tuesday morning when three survivors were discovered and safely removed.

About 450 people were also injured in the incident, which is Japan's worst since a train collision killed 161 people near Tokyo in 1963.

The crash has prompted questions about Japan's railway system, which handles 60 million passenger journeys every day and which has been regarded as one of the world's safest.

JAPAN RAIL CRASH
1: Crash happened at 0020GMT at end of morning rush-hour
2: Seven-carriage train had 580 people aboard
3: Four of the carriages derailed (one not visible)





LINKS TO MORE ASIA-PACIFIC STORIES


 

BBC NEWS: VIDEO AND AUDIO
Why recovering the driver's body has taken so long



RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

TOP ASIA-PACIFIC STORIES NOW

News alerts | E-mail services | Desktop ticker | Mobiles/PDAs
News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
BBC Homepage >> | BBC Sport >> | BBC Weather >> | BBC World Service >>
newswatchNotes | Contact us | About BBC News | Profiles | History
bannerwatch listenbbc sportAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific